In the original 'Peter Pan' play, Peter was played by a female actress. Does this make Peter a girl? No.
NintendoWiiForever wrote:sheik is just zelda disguised as a man...making him a women.
since when is a manga that you found on the internet proof? i don't feel you proved anything.
if you were to actually examine sheik ...like i have, you would notice that his crotch is female as well his booty. what makes a man a man and a woman a woman is all in the pants.
sheik is only supposed to portray a man.
if i cross dressed and made my self look like a woman then i would still be a man.
for more proof examine sheiks feminine legs, feminine hands and feminine eyes
[img=mini]http://www.ganonstower.com/wallpapers/sheik_800x600.jpg[/img]In the original 'Peter Pan' play, Peter was played by a female actress. Does this make Peter a girl? No.
really that is not a good argument. your comparing an actor (or in this case, actress) to the world of video games and the plot of loz which are completely unrelated. it is not relevant at all. worst argument i have ever heard.
actually you just proved my point! just because that actress dressed and portrayed a boy does not mean she is a boy.
think of it this way: if zelda weren't underneath, and sheik was a real person, what gender would s/he be?
I am a girl, but i dress up in boys clothes, and start calling myself 'Tommy'. Everybody thinks that I am a boy. Does that make me a boy? ( The correct answer is 'Hell No', underneath the clothes, i still have girl parts, i still think like a girl, and consider myself a girl)
Leonado di Vinci once stated that "the chair can be destroyed, so it is not real. But the idea of the chair cannot be destroyed, so it is real" this is the same thing with Sheik, the idea of Sheik is a Male but the Sheik itself is just Zelda, a Female.
cortjezter wrote:this isn't even a thread about zelda. it's about shiek. forget zelda. going back to the halloween analogy, because it is exactly the same principle:
cortjezter wrote:if you were a guy and dressed up as peach in a costume, peach wouldn't be a guy just because there's a guy under the costume. unfortunately in shiek's case, the line between male or female isn't immediately visible.
cortjezter wrote:but because it's a character meant to be anything but zelda and looks more masculine than feminine, i'm inclined to believe that means shiek is a guy.
cortjezter wrote:besides, in the real world, 'shiek' is a male term.
cortjezter wrote:again, an extensive discourse that completely misses my points and doesn't seem to understand any of what i wrote... i guess it truly is a never-ending debate. some will think and focus on zelda, where i think she's irrelevant.
Next-Gen-Gamer wrote:cortjezter wrote:again, an extensive discourse that completely misses my points and doesn't seem to understand any of what i wrote... i guess it truly is a never-ending debate. some will think and focus on zelda, where i think she's irrelevant.
How can Zelda be irrelevant? She's turns into Sheik, therefor she is Sheik. Regardless of gender, it's always Zelda. That's what I'm getting at. How can you make a valid point in a debate that only exists because of Zelda?
jab wrote: Somewhere on the internet is a picture of a page from the manga that easaly explains a lot.
stinklesAFI wrote:jab wrote: Somewhere on the internet is a picture of a page from the manga that easaly explains a lot.
yeah you just shot yourself in the foot here, you need to remember that just because it's on the internet doesn't mean it's true.
Creedy316 wrote:Sheik is Zelda. who is a girl. dressing herself up as a male sheikah as a disguise to hide from ganondorf.
so technically. sheik's a girl. disguised as a male.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users