Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancellation

Get your discussion on with the blog stories. Moderation is less strict, but topics have short lives...quick!

Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancellation

Postby robometal cowboy » 30 Apr 2012 22:38

Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancellation
Click Here to View Story

There's been a bit of hot activity on Twitter concerning the cancellation of La-Mulana, with quite a few people calling out publisher Nicalis for the game's issues. In the middle of the conversation, Renegade Kid's Jools Watsham threw in his two cents.


@nicalis was the publisher for La Mulana. They did everything they could to publish it. But... if the developer can't deliver a stable build to @nicalis, there's nothing for them to publish.

It's always nice hearing input on these situations from other devs out there in the mix. I'd say this speaks well for Nicalis' side of the argument.

Link
User avatar
robometal cowboy
Site Bot
Site Bot
 
Posts: 30551
Joined: 13 Dec 2009 00:23

Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancellation

Postby LegendofSantiago » 30 Apr 2012 22:39

Are people picking on Nicalis because of La-Mulana? really?
User avatar
LegendofSantiago
Pokemon Trainer
Pokemon Trainer
 
Posts: 1026
Joined: 22 Jan 2012 10:15

Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancellation

Postby BigLord » 30 Apr 2012 22:39

@LegendofSantiago
Dey be mad, aye.
Show me your news!
User avatar
BigLord
Octorok
Octorok
 
Posts: 167
Joined: 26 Jun 2009 17:35

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby PaperLink64 » 30 Apr 2012 22:45

LegendofSantiago wrote:Are people picking on Nicalis because of La-Mulana? really?


They have plenty of reasons to be picked on, La-Mulana's just the newest reason for their skewering.
User avatar
PaperLink64
Piranha Plant
Piranha Plant
 
Posts: 225
Joined: 08 Nov 2008 02:26
Location: The Bionis
Wii: 6643-1766-9039-6758
PSN: PaperLink64HD
3DS: 1805-3015-8051

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby ninjablaze » 30 Apr 2012 22:50

They did deliver a stable build, though. The master copy was sent to them about a week ago.

Nicalis just had the shocking overnight revelation that WiiWare isn't such a hot market anymore. They're just as much to blame for waiting this long, and waiting until after they already had the finished game in their hands, to cancel it as Nigoro is for taking forever to develop it.
User avatar
ninjablaze
Chocobo
Chocobo
 
Posts: 41
Joined: 31 May 2009 22:38
Wii: too lazy to find it
XBL: IcyBlaze Ninja
PSN: IcyBlazeNinja
3DS: 3308-4568-5088
NN ID: Icyblaze_Ninja

Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancellation

Postby LegendofSantiago » 30 Apr 2012 22:53

@PaperLink64 Well, they are cancelling a game for a "dead" service for a console that is on it's way out and the game has been in a long development cycle and apparently hasn't made a lot of progress. You can be angry at the constant cave story re-releases (i won't, i'll buy them all), all the delays for europe, etc but i don't think they are entirely in the wrong. I really dislike wiiware although I actually like the wii. At least how wiiware is now. I don't want to see more developers who actually like Nintendo put a good game on this service since it isn't a very good one, at least when compared to things like the new e-shop.
User avatar
LegendofSantiago
Pokemon Trainer
Pokemon Trainer
 
Posts: 1026
Joined: 22 Jan 2012 10:15

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby PaperLink64 » 30 Apr 2012 22:57

LegendofSantiago wrote:@PaperLink64 Well, they are cancelling a game for a "dead" service for a console that is on it's way out and the game has been in a long development cycle and apparently hasn't made a lot of progress. You can be angry at the constant cave story re-releases (i won't, i'll buy them all), all the delays for europe, etc but i don't think they are entirely in the wrong. I really dislike wiiware although I actually like the wii. At least how wiiware is now. I don't want to see more developers who actually like Nintendo put a good game on this service since it isn't a very good one, at least when compared to things like the new e-shop.


Not really too angry over La-Mulana, my beef with them is their inability to release titles on a timely basis. And even then, Nicalis still somehow screws up their ports like Cave Story WiiWare being pretty glitchy or VVVVVV 3DS initally releasing with Flip mode crashing the game.
User avatar
PaperLink64
Piranha Plant
Piranha Plant
 
Posts: 225
Joined: 08 Nov 2008 02:26
Location: The Bionis
Wii: 6643-1766-9039-6758
PSN: PaperLink64HD
3DS: 1805-3015-8051

Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancellation

Postby Battlestriker123 » 30 Apr 2012 23:21

The thing about this is that the development cycle has been openly discussed before. There were some points in which the devs and Nicalis had some problems with each other, which may have led to this current heated discussion.

Case in point: the comment below XD
Last edited by Battlestriker123 on 30 Apr 2012 23:39, edited 1 time in total.
Favorite Game: Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga (GBA)
Just Finished: Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon (3DS)
Now Playing: Professor Layton and the Miracle Mask (3DS)
Follow me on MyIGN! http://people.ign.com/battlestriker123
User avatar
Battlestriker123
Metool
Metool
 
Posts: 330
Joined: 04 Sep 2011 20:02
Location: Stardust Fields, Beanbean Kingdom
3DS: 3539-8800-5372
NN ID: Battlestriker123

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby Devil_Rising » 30 Apr 2012 23:33

That is a heaping amount of BULLS***, plain and simple. They HAD a "stable build", but they failed to get past ONE stupid German ratings board, so they didn't release it ANYWHERE on WiiWare? Just fantastic. Just absolutely fantastic.

BTW, Nicalis sucks as a publisher, and shouldn't be defended. This isn't the first thing they've messed up. I say, screw Germany, they should have just released in everywhere ELSE. But nope.....
Image
Also featured at: http://thepunkeffect.com
Follow along on Twitter: @RetroRevelation
User avatar
Devil_Rising
Pokemon Trainer
Pokemon Trainer
 
Posts: 1178
Joined: 27 May 2009 13:03
PSN: AwesomeFukenGuy
NN ID: Godzilla1981

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby Iridium077 » 30 Apr 2012 23:47

Devil_Rising wrote:I say, screw Germany, they should have just released in everywhere ELSE. But nope.....


Aha, but if it were the United States and Canada being shafted, you'd be far more hesitant to say that in hopes that the problem might eventually be solved. I understand what you're getting at, but I think there are ways to say that without coming off as a jerk.

That having been said, while I do not support Nicalis under normal circumstances, they are hardly in the wrong in this one case. Wiiware has a terrible market, a terrible selection, and works... terribly. Do you know, for instance, that a game needs to meet certain sales quotas for the publisher to receive even a single cent of profit from the game?

It's not that I'm not sad about this - I am - but frankly, at this point and with this little effort from Nintendo to remedy the system, Nintendo doesn't deserve to have quality releases on Wiiware. If they want games like La-Mulana, they need to create a system that actually works...

...like, oh, say, the eShop. Nicalis, in case you were wondering, that was your cue.
User avatar
Iridium077
Shyguy
Shyguy
 
Posts: 106
Joined: 03 Jun 2011 00:43
PSN: Jean_Descole
NN ID: Iridium

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby gojiguy » 01 May 2012 01:18

The sad part is, with a few little tweaks WiiWare could've been glorious (none of this sales quota BS, much higher download cap, etc)
User avatar
gojiguy
Waddle Dee
Waddle Dee
 
Posts: 83
Joined: 09 Nov 2008 17:02

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby chambertlo » 01 May 2012 01:53

Why is this game not being released for the e-shop? Oh well, there is always Kickstarter.
User avatar
chambertlo
Goomba
Goomba
 
Posts: 21
Joined: 08 Apr 2011 04:50

Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancellation

Postby kdognumba1 » 01 May 2012 02:00

@chambertlo

Indeed. I hope they get this out on the eShop.
Image
User avatar
kdognumba1
Metool
Metool
 
Posts: 341
Joined: 12 Jun 2011 00:21
Location: Texas
Wii: 5726-8719-5929-3614
XBL: kdog254
PSN: jotaroxtreme
3DS: 1676-3698-5986
NN ID: kdog254

Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancellation

Postby MoldyClay » 01 May 2012 02:04

@LegendofSantiago

While I agree with you that it is a waste to put anything on WiiWare (because it is. Honestly, other than exclusives, I don't know why anyone would have bought anything on it after a certain point. And even then; I don't blame Nicalis for canceling, some companies for not making WiiWare versions of anything and so on), I also think it is stupid that they led people on and then were apparently given a final/stable build and cancel.

Someone involved is lying or not being entirely clear.

I personally stopped caring about the game *because* it wasn't coming out, and honestly, I don't even remember what it is besides the name.

That's cool that you're okay with Nicalis taking a freeware game and selling 4 different versions, but it basically means they are a one-trick pony and they didn't even make the game or do anything amazing. Their claim to fame is charging people for something. Meh.

Personally, I am glad people are annoyed though, because I thought they were giving Nicalis a free pass while being annoyed at Team Meat.
User avatar
MoldyClay
Pokemon Trainer
Pokemon Trainer
 
Posts: 1241
Joined: 25 Feb 2008 04:34
Location: Wantage, NJ
Wii: 5586 1294 0421 8289
XBL: MoldyClay87
PSN: moldyclay
3DS: 3050-8737-8491

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby KingBroly » 01 May 2012 02:06

You should be annoyed at Nicalis now. They didn't tell the game's developer before-hand that they were cancelling the WiiWare version in NA/EU
Mega Man 9 isn't hard, you're just not paying attention
Sakamoto Lied. Samus Died.
I write things here from time to time
User avatar
KingBroly
Site Mod
Site Mod
 
Posts: 3966
Joined: 12 Apr 2007 00:41
Location: North Carolina
Wii: 8135-0917-9758-1594
XBL: KingBroly
PSN: KingBroly
3DS: 3351-4164-6416
NN ID: KingBroly

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby Linkstrikesback » 01 May 2012 02:31

KingBroly wrote:You should be annoyed at Nicalis now. They didn't tell the game's developer before-hand that they were cancelling the WiiWare version in NA/EU


Because it's only just been decided. Do you own a time machine? No? Ah, well, then it's likely not many people do and therefore Nicalis probably did not know they were cancelling it...until they decided to.

Seriously though, the La Mulana guy has been giving nicalis builds that nintendo has been rejecting for almost two years now, what suddenly makes you people think the "final" version he gave them would have passed? Because he said so? :roll:
Linkstrikesback
Fairy
Fairy
 
Posts: 0
Joined: 20 Dec 2011 19:04

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby Devil_Rising » 01 May 2012 04:03

Iridium077 wrote:
Aha, but if it were the United States and Canada being shafted, you'd be far more hesitant to say that in hopes that the problem might eventually be solved. I understand what you're getting at, but I think there are ways to say that without coming off as a jerk.

That having been said, while I do not support Nicalis under normal circumstances, they are hardly in the wrong in this one case. Wiiware has a terrible market, a terrible selection, and works... terribly. Do you know, for instance, that a game needs to meet certain sales quotas for the publisher to receive even a single cent of profit from the game?

It's not that I'm not sad about this - I am - but frankly, at this point and with this little effort from Nintendo to remedy the system, Nintendo doesn't deserve to have quality releases on Wiiware. If they want games like La-Mulana, they need to create a system that actually works...

...like, oh, say, the eShop. Nicalis, in case you were wondering, that was your cue.



Not really. How is it "being a jerk", to say screw ONE country, for the benefit of every other country, when it comes to getting a game? That has literally been the holdup for the better part of a year now. I don't really care if I "sound like a jerk" or not. I didn't realize the entire nation of Germany was "listening in" on this conversation. And besides, it's nothing against Germans personally, it's the fact that North America is a FAR bigger video game market than Germany anyway. It isn't even the entire EU that's the hold up, it was LITERALLY just Germany.

As for WiiWare "sucking" or "working terribly", I don't know about that either. Yes, it's had it's problems. But to tell you the truth, owning both a Wii and a PS3, there have been a LOT more WiiWare games I've actually wanted to bother checking out over the years than PSN, and that's a fact. There have been a few gems on PSN, to be sure. But WiiWare has had a LOT more quality games that I've downloaded and enjoyed, not the least of which being: Konami's "Rebirth" series (Gradius, Castlevania, Contra), Cave Story, the LostWinds games, Max and the Magic Marker, Bust a Move and Bubble Bobble Plus, Tetris, Dr. Mario, Fluidity, Toki Tori, Blast Master: Overdrive, World of Goo, the Art Style series, the Bit.Trip series, Excitebike: World Rally, FFIV: The After Years, Bomberman Blast, Adventure Island, Nyx Quest, etc. etc.

Point being, there's been plenty of quality games. The service itself may not be the best it could be, but to knock the games is a bit of a stretch. Sure, it's slowed down in the last year or so, but what do you expect, it's late in the console's life?


Linkstrikesback wrote:
KingBroly wrote:You should be annoyed at Nicalis now. They didn't tell the game's developer before-hand that they were cancelling the WiiWare version in NA/EU


Because it's only just been decided. Do you own a time machine? No? Ah, well, then it's likely not many people do and therefore Nicalis probably did not know they were cancelling it...until they decided to.

Seriously though, the La Mulana guy has been giving nicalis builds that nintendo has been rejecting for almost two years now, what suddenly makes you people think the "final" version he gave them would have passed? Because he said so? :roll:



First off, you don't need to be so snide. Secondly, you don't need a time machine to know information you don't seem to be privy to. Third, Nigoro isn't a "he", it's a development team, and they DID have a complete build finished LAST YEAR. They submitted it, and it passed EVERY ratings board, except one. A German ratings board. It's never been an issue with NOA. Nicalis should have just pushed the damn thing through to North America. Europe has a history of getting things late, they could have waited again. But why keeps us in NA from getting it AT ALL, just because they wanted to wait and release it at the same time? It makes no sense, and for them to turn around and cancel the game without telling Nigoro that they are, is moronic and underhanded. Them throwing Nigoro under the bus and blaming it all on them, is also unprofessional and pretty immature.

Ever hear of NightSky? Nicalis has been "handling" the publishing of that game too. Yet it's MIA on WiiWare, it's original platform. It came out on Steam, and it's supposed to come to the eShop for 3DS, but no WiiWare version, even though it was announced in like 2009. Do you think it's THAT developer's fault too, and only a coincidence that Nicalis happens to be involved with both? I don't. In fact I know that's not the case, and that it's rather the other way around. NightSky will never see the light of day on WiiWare for the same reason that La-Mulana now never will: because Nicalis is a bad publisher, that doesn't show initiative and doesn't seem to communicate well with developers.

In fact, the blog for Nigoro was just updated recently. They sounded like the game was still coming out. Meaning they didn't yet know it was being cancelled. You'd think that the developer would be the FIRST person you told, not the media, that your game isn't being released through them. Now, Nigoro could always try and get it published through someone else, but who knows? Fact is, by the tone of their blogs over the last year or so, they've had the game finished, polished and out the door long before now, and that it's been a ridiculous ratings hold-up over in Germany of all places, along with ratings groups apparently also being terribly uncommunicative with them.

So just a word of advice: You might want to know what you're talking about, before you try to sound like you know what you're talking about.
Image
Also featured at: http://thepunkeffect.com
Follow along on Twitter: @RetroRevelation
User avatar
Devil_Rising
Pokemon Trainer
Pokemon Trainer
 
Posts: 1178
Joined: 27 May 2009 13:03
PSN: AwesomeFukenGuy
NN ID: Godzilla1981

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby Frank » 01 May 2012 06:55

Devil_Rising wrote:That is a heaping amount of BULLS***, plain and simple. They HAD a "stable build", but they failed to get past ONE stupid German ratings board, so they didn't release it ANYWHERE on WiiWare? Just fantastic. Just absolutely fantastic.

Is that really true? Do you have a source? I'd just be surprised if the reason it isn't coming out in NA is because it can't get past an EU ratings board, given that it took nearly a year from NA to EU to get Cave Story on WW and still doesn't have Cave Story on DSi or VVVVVV.

As an aside, if it can't get released in any one country in EU, it won't be released in any of them. Not sure if that's a Nintendo rule or an EU one, but they wouldn't be able to release it anywhere in the EU if Germany won't pass it.
User avatar
Frank
Shyguy
Shyguy
 
Posts: 105
Joined: 11 Dec 2009 16:15

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby ludist210 » 01 May 2012 08:04

Frank wrote:Is that really true? Do you have a source? I'd just be surprised if the reason it isn't coming out in NA is because it can't get past an EU ratings board, given that it took nearly a year from NA to EU to get Cave Story on WW and still doesn't have Cave Story on DSi or VVVVVV.
Well, La-Mulana had been "stable" in Japan for about a year, so...
ludist210
Fairy
Fairy
 
Posts: 2
Joined: 28 May 2009 11:37
NN ID: Ludist210

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby Legromancer » 01 May 2012 08:34

@Devil_Rising: you know what, i am sick of reading how bad Germany is and how we are alway responsible for every bad thing. I really sucks being German on the Internet. Not one week passes without reading another bullshit about ,,banned'' games etc. And clearly the people talking about knowing shovel about the laws in Germany. I tealy sucks, and after years of this bullshit i gave up hope. People will not inform, they will keep talking bullshit because...well it's Germany after all, isn't it?
Legromancer
Fairy
Fairy
 
Posts: 1
Joined: 08 Nov 2008 18:35

Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancellation

Postby Red » 01 May 2012 08:36

Tough luck for Nicalis that this is a bullet they probably can't dodge either way. While it's hard to blame any publisher for realizing what a lovely marketplace WiiWare is nowadays, at the end of the day Nicalis
a) already is plenty notorious for issues with their publishing of CaveStory Wii, CaveStory DSi, NightSky and vvvvvv. In other words pretty much any project of note they ever worked on.
b) is taking the classy way out by almost entirely putting the blame on Nigoro in a semi-nonchalant way.
c) is verbally putting this issue aside without considering/thinking aloud of possible eShop/WiiU endeavors. Not blaming them for this one per se, as a eShop revamp is probably an entirely new issue (and not necessarily out of the window) and I don't expect anyone being clairvoyant about WiiU's digital marketplace, but in marketing there's always that deliciously vague way out by implying that things went ugly, but "you're thinking of something".

I honestly can't see this as anything but another dent in Nicalis' already pretty lovely resume and there's a reason why it's already becoming kind of a sad running gag to worry about any title Nicalis picks up for publishing.


I'm also not entirely sure how powerful the USK-card is in this blame game. According to their site, La-Mulana got its initial rating of USK12 back in 2010 already, roughly 5 months after the Japanese release. Admittedly things got ugly exactly around then with the whole semi-renewal of the rating system, which may have invalidated the former rating for the time being (sadly, publishing IS pretty anal about things like that...), but even then La-Mulana seems to have kept its USK12 rating since August 4th 2011. That sure took a while, but come on, that was still the beginning of August last year. We've got May 2012 now.
User avatar
Red
Goomba
Goomba
 
Posts: 19
Joined: 29 May 2009 14:57
Location: Germany

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby V3N0M » 01 May 2012 11:55

Well damn first MDK and now this. You'd think with all the attention wiiware has been getting now would be the perfect time to release it out into the wild. Any publicity is good publicity as they say, and you gotta strike while the irons hot! Ah well if it doesnt work out I think Nicalis should aim for seeing hte game get a release on the e-shop or wii-u Nintendo network service when its up and running. Certianly got me interested in a game I had really no prior knowledge about. Hey Jools don't just defend your fellow devs out with a simple tweet, help your brothers out and get them on the road to releasing this game for the e-shop. :)
User avatar
V3N0M
Waddle Dee
Waddle Dee
 
Posts: 79
Joined: 13 Feb 2010 02:28
Location: Japan
3DS: 5455-9364-4253

Re: Renegade Kid sticks up for Nicalis in La-Mulana cancella

Postby Devil_Rising » 01 May 2012 13:56

Frank wrote:
Devil_Rising wrote:That is a heaping amount of BULLS***, plain and simple. They HAD a "stable build", but they failed to get past ONE stupid German ratings board, so they didn't release it ANYWHERE on WiiWare? Just fantastic. Just absolutely fantastic.

Is that really true? Do you have a source? I'd just be surprised if the reason it isn't coming out in NA is because it can't get past an EU ratings board, given that it took nearly a year from NA to EU to get Cave Story on WW and still doesn't have Cave Story on DSi or VVVVVV.

As an aside, if it can't get released in any one country in EU, it won't be released in any of them. Not sure if that's a Nintendo rule or an EU one, but they wouldn't be able to release it anywhere in the EU if Germany won't pass it.



http://la-mulana.com/en/

The most official a source can get. The official developer blog. I've been keeping up on it for over a year.



@Legromancer

Well, no offense, but perhaps your country needs to get a little better with some of their stringent ratings policies when it comes to games. I didn't say Germany was a bad country, nor did I say anything about Germans, so I think you need to calm the hell down. What I SAID was, why should the REST of the western gaming world have to do without what honestly looks like an awesome update/remake of this game, that Nigoro obviously put a LOT of time and effort into, JUST because one German ratings board are a bunch of stiff asses and wouldn't pass it? In that case, Germany doesn't need to get it then. That sucks to say, and it SUCKS for German gamers, but I didn't make it that way, and neither did the developer.

But why should we in NA have to do without this game completely, because it got held up for so long by one European ratings board? It makes exactly zero sense. So I'm sorry if you're offending because you took my comments the wrong way. To be fair, I guess I understand somewhat where you're coming from. But really, you didn't need to reply like that. I was talking about a game, not Germany the country, or Germans as a people.

Chill out, relax, and have a nice day.
Image
Also featured at: http://thepunkeffect.com
Follow along on Twitter: @RetroRevelation
User avatar
Devil_Rising
Pokemon Trainer
Pokemon Trainer
 
Posts: 1178
Joined: 27 May 2009 13:03
PSN: AwesomeFukenGuy
NN ID: Godzilla1981


Return to GoNintendo Blog Story Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users